The following are various staff reactions to ‘You Can See Everything,” a three-hour documentary in which disgraced Theranos founder Elizabeth Holmes invited a comedian and movie director to film her and her family 34 days before she went to prison.
Um. What?
What, exactly, did I just sit through for three hours inside Minneapolis’ downtown Main cinema, hopped up like a little boy on cookie dough bites and Pibb Extra at midnight early Friday morning with fellow former reporter Ian Wreisner, who initially commented that comedian Nathan Fielder resembled his sleep paralysis demon?
The documentary gets Holmes’ litigation VERY quickly out of the way so it can settle on its actual premise for the first half: Fielder is far more interested in who Holmes is at this period in her life, as a mother and partner to Billy Evans, the son of a rich hotel mogul who ends up being, honestly, the most important person in this film. All while prison looms like Fielder’s visage through the window, staring as she plays with her children. (This was, shall we say, a fascinating quirk).
If I had to guess, Holmes is someone who has constructed a kind of cocoon around her psyche. Pulling something like Theranos off requires, by psychological necessity, decades of lying to oneself about one’s own “glorious purpose,” as the trickster god Loki would put it. At no point does Holmes strike the viewer as a deliberate con artist.
The second half of this documentary isn’t about Holmes. Not really. This is a documentary that, without giving away specifics, becomes about how Holmes’ persona was and is still used for profit at multiple turns, how this reinforced and still reinforces Theranos’ popularity and lies, and what it says about, frankly, how my job in news media can go sometimes.
We get something in this office called press releases. And I’m not accusing anyone who has sent me these of BSing me, but think for a minute about what a press release is: It’s one source’s version of events. When something like Theranos spreads like wildfire, and Holmes is delivering mainstream news interviews and TedTalks, that way of breaking stories and information gets harder to put out than one might assume.
Fielder is not a normal documentarian. He takes multiple bold and dare I say cocky risks that take the documentary form out of “real” and into something like “hyper-real.” Because in a case like Holmes, where logic has no meaning, how does one even go about documentation or objectivity? It’s impossible.
Oh yeah, don’t forget about Lance Oppenheim’s direction on this. He handles so much of the cinematography brilliantly. Holmes’ piercing stare is sure to not go away for another decade after he helped pull this off.
Elliot Steeves, Anoka-Blaine-Coon Rapids reporter
3 people, 3 dealsOne of my favorite parts about this documentary is the massive discourse happening about it online.
I’m not the type to turn to reviews or Reddit before I decide how I feel about a movie. Yet the evening I spent after watching the film, but before Instagram started queueing “You Can See Everything” takes, was a lonely one indeed.
The online takes are copious. Everyone, from Theranos’ whistleblower Tyler Shultz to actor and podcaster Dax Shepard have brought interesting tidbits to the conversation. It feels like the internet has finally found a way to come together, and it’s out of a mutual desire to decide, once and for all, what the deal is with this unblinking, disgraced CEO and her semiferal, lip-licking partner.
Going into this, I knew a little about Holmes, but a whole lot more about Nathan Fielder, who leads the film as the documentarian invited to live in the Holmes-Evans oceanside abode in the final weeks before Holmes checks into prison. For the past few years, Fielder has been operating on a truly strange, wholly unique comedic wavelength on his HBO show, “The Rehearsal.”
For those who have watched his reality-meets-absurdity schtick ramp up across this show and his 2010s show, “Nathan for You”, the announcement of the documentary was a sign that Fielder, again, had levelled up his — well, whatever his deal is.
And that’s what I found so compelling about the documentary itself. All three of these people captured so intimately on camera have deals, and all three attempt to thwart, lean in, circumvent and obfuscate them, until they’re impossible to ignore — the beach house is much too small for three elephants, let alone one.
Sure, Evans and Holmes work very hard to bare the “realest” version of themselves, letting cameras in on the mundanity of their lives — every scrambled-egg beating, Zoom-calling, brushing teeth in the shower moment. But we know to do this, they are stepping over cameras in every corner of the beach cottage. We see Fielder, third-wheeling in the corner, looking for his moment of absurdity in reality. We see Evans’ ever-moistening lips, every pregnant pause in Holmes’ speech. This is not a cozy space that invites its inhabitants to come as they are, it’s a cramped one in which exhaustively-curated personas are being forced to prove themselves, over and over.
And whether Holmes and Evans pass your personal authenticity test, you leave the theater thinking, who but a couple so doggedly set on keeping something going would seek out this treatment?
Alaina Rooker, senior managing editor
‘A rollercoaster of uncomfortability’A journalist, a cross country coach and a Mormon walk into a movie theater. It sounds like the beginning of a potentially problematic joke, but in actuality, it’s just my go-to crew for a trip to the movies as of late. It’s a way for the three of us keep in touch despite going down different paths after high school, providing fodder for discussion even once we go our separate ways.
Boy, did this movie give us plenty to talk about.
We spent nearly three hours laughing, cringing and watching unbelievable moments play out with our mouths agape. Time flew by as we experienced this rollercoaster of uncomfortability, which ultimately invites the viewer question the very nature of truth.
We all got something different out of this movie, but we all enjoyed it immensely.
My recommendation: watch “You Can See Everything” with as little background information as possible. It’s a wild ride.
Jack Wiedner, Brooklyn Park-Brooklyn Center community editor
Who is that good of a liar?I saw the film with a close friend, which is great because I know she wasn’t weirded out by my constantly looking over at her with a horrified expression, usually in reaction to something Billy Evans said. Truly, I have never felt so much disdain for someone upon first introduction, but every time he was on screen, there was a more sinister energy to it than anything I’ve seen yet this Halloween.
There is an arc to the documentary that leads the audience to wonder what Holmes’ true intentions were and still are. Questions were posed: could she have meant well? Were her statements about Theranos simply poorly phrased?
At first I was right there with Fielder. This couple was so open to having a film crew in their home, essentially being surveilled 24/7 by a man who was initially convinced of Holmes’ guilt, so what could they have to hide that Fielder wouldn’t have uncovered? As a part of their self-proclaimed radical transparency, the couple was often seen showing love to each other and their children. As a viewer, it was difficult to identify my “take” on Holmes’ guilt when I am able to see what I can only assume is her real personality. Because who is that good of a liar?
Immediately after my friend and I left the theater, we started sharing our theories. I believe there’s a facade at play, as many others probably do. I remember telling my friend that I thought Holmes patted her baby’s back as a nervous tick as she lied. Maybe that’s another crazy conspiracy theory in a long line of them, but who really knows.
The audience is taken on a journey to find the truth, and that we did. The truth is people are multifaceted, confusing, selfish, deceitful and can be empathetic even toward the subjects of their suspicion. “You Can See Everything” is an intimate, jarring documentary that puts your discernment to the ultimate test. Fielder’s unrelenting curiosity and ability to ask the most revealing, yet awkward, questions is hilarious and refreshing. I highly recommend giving this a watch, but be prepared to pick your jaw up off the floor as the credits roll.
Lila Swedzinski, Anoka-Blaine-Coon Rapids reporter