The East Bethel City Council reaffirmed its denial of Sota Storage’s proposed expansion Oct. 26, citing the company’s failure to complete improvements required under earlier city approvals.

The unanimous vote formalized the council’s Oct. 12 rejection of a request for a conditional use permit and site plan review for the self-storage facility at 20563 Aberdeen St. NE. The council also agreed to allow a shorter wait to reapply.

Sota sought approval for a continued phased expansion, according to a memo from City Planner Eric Johnson. The Planning Commission recommended approval with conditions.

Council members questioned whether the company would meet requirements for additional development when work required under previous approvals remained unfinished.

Johnson said the outstanding requirements included landscaping, lighting updates, removal of barbed wire, drainage systems and secondary access for firefighters.

Council Member Suzanne Erkel said the company could have taken advantage of the pleasant fall weather to begin some of the work.

“I don’t really trust this company, to be honest with you,” Erkel said. “Honestly right now with our experience of storage companies in East Bethel, I don’t trust any of them.”

Erkel questioned why approval was presented as an option when the facility had been out of compliance for six years. She said she was open to tabling the application because she did not want to penalize the company financially.

Johnson said the company would ordinarily have to wait about a year to reapply after a denial, but the council could shorten that period.

City Administrator Matt Look said the goal was to bring the facility into compliance and that the company had an opportunity to do so.

“You do have the conditional use permit that could be revoked,” Look said. “That’s the nuclear option. I don’t know if we want to go that way. But we do want them to comply with what they agreed to.”

Look said the next steps were up to the company and warned that denying the permit could lead to a contentious situation.

Erkel said revoking the existing permit could be costly and lead to legal complications, but she did not want to approve an expansion while the facility remained out of compliance with its existing permit.

Council Member Brian Mundle asked whether the decision could specify that the application would return to the council once the conditions were met. Council Member Jim Smith said he thought that had been clear at the previous meeting and suggested the facility had not obtained a certificate of occupancy.

“It’s like we’re babysitting,” Smith said. “We shouldn’t be.”

Look said a denial would require the company to restart the application process. Smith responded that the company had failed to complete the required paperwork in the first place.

“Let them start over,” Smith said. “Otherwise, we’re just creating another mess. We can make the time period shorter than a year. I have no problem with that. Come back with your stuff done, get your CO like you should have, and then we can shorten the period.”

Mayor Ardie Anderson asked whether the denial would lead to litigation. City Attorney Mark Berglund said it would not, citing the facility’s failure to meet city requirements.

Erkel said she preferred denying the application and allowing the company to reapply sooner. Anderson said repeating the application process would result in additional legal fees.

Council Member Dino Perfetti asked who had spoken with Sota’s legal representative. Johnson said he had.

Berglund said East Bethel’s code enforcement was driven by complaints, addressing questions about how the facility had remained out of compliance for so long.

“If no one’s complaining about it, we’re not out there crawling over their fence and seeing what’s going on,” Berglund said. “And so there hadn’t been any complaints that brought them to the attention of the city to do enforcement actions on.”

Berglund said the company would still incur expenses if it reapplied, and the city could not waive those costs because it had denied the previous application.

Johnson said allowing Sota to construct its next three buildings without bringing the facility into compliance or bringing the matter before the city would have been more egregious than denying the application. He said the facility was a legal nonconforming use and had been granted an expansion during its six years in East Bethel.

Original Article