The Columbia Heights City Council unanimously upheld the revocation of a rental license Oct. 26 after repeated inspections found an unsafe deck railing and a cockroach infestation at a home on Polk Street Northeast.

The council also reduced the fee to apply for a new license by one-third amid concerns that the revocation could displace a family living in the home.

The rental license for the property at 3957 Polk St. NE was revoked after violations first identified April 22 remained unresolved through multiple reinspections, according to a report from Assistant Fire Chief Brad Roddy.

Property owner Alioune Thiam appealed the revocation July 27, three days after another inspection found the violations had not been corrected.

Subsequent inspections Oct. 5 and Oct. 19 found the same unresolved issues.

The revocation was the first involving a rental property in which Thiam held an interest within the past five years.

Roddy said the Fire Department had requested documentation of all extermination work conducted at the property following the April 22 inspection.

A Green Pest Control service agreement dated May 22 outlined a treatment plan for the home. However, Roddy said Thiam did not begin submitting pest control documentation until five months after the initial inspection.

Those records appeared incomplete and included older service dates, leaving questions about whether treatments had continued during the intervening months. Inspectors also identified problems with the workmanship of the deck railing.

“While we recognize that some corrective action has occurred, the violations were not satisfactorily resolved at the time of revocation,” Roddy said, “and the cockroach infestation remained an ongoing concern during our most recent inspection.”

Thiam, who said he has owned the property since 2009, expressed surprise at the license revocation and maintained that he had made considerable efforts to address the violations.

“I was coming here today optimistic that, even though he’s right, that I was not giving them the documentation to something, but I was not clear that was what I was supposed to do,” Thiam said. “…Before even they came, we identified the issues. The tenant and I worked together and we tried to treat it.”

Thiam said he subsequently hired three different professionals to address the problems but was unsuccessful in fully resolving them. He also maintained that he did not realize the property had failed its inspections until he received a letter notifying him of the violations.

“I swear to you, I went back to the house and fixed every single item,” Thiam said.

Thiam said he believed the problems had been resolved and that he had submitted sufficient documentation. He maintained that inspectors had not clearly communicated whether his corrective actions met the city’s requirements.

Council Member Connie Buesgens expressed sympathy for the tenants but emphasized that landlords are responsible for maintaining their properties.

“Cockroaches are not acceptable,” Buesgens said. “They’re not acceptable. Period. When they showed up in the house, they should have been taken care of before the inspectors came into this property to inspect it.”

Buesgens acknowledged Thiam’s previous record of maintaining the home but said that did not excuse the violations.

“That porch, that railing should have never been in disrepair. Ever,” Buesgens said. “That house should have been pristine just like the house you live in. Everyone here takes care of their homes, and that’s your responsibility.”

Mayor Amada Márquez Simula was more sympathetic to Thiam’s position, saying she could understand how a landlord might believe a property was in compliance after making repairs.

“I’m very concerned about the family being displaced,” Simula said. “…Housing is such a huge issue right now, and there are people that I’ve already been working with in totally different situations that are trying to find housing.”

Simula also pointed to Thiam’s history of maintaining multiple rental properties and favored giving him a short period to complete the necessary corrections.

Council Member Rachel James expressed concern that Thiam may have continued collecting rent after the license was revoked. She said landlords cannot legally collect rent on properties without valid rental licenses.

However, James also acknowledged the work Thiam had undertaken to address the violations.

“I do see a lot of progress, and I’m really appreciative of the documentation that has been provided and the work that has been done and the track record that you have,” James said.

James noted that cockroach infestations can be particularly difficult to eliminate, sometimes requiring treatments every other week for several months.

City Manager Aaron Chirpich explained that granting the appeal would effectively reverse the license revocation. However, he said Thiam also had a path to obtaining a new rental license if the council upheld the decision.

“There is, in front of them right now, the opportunity to relicense,” Chirpich said. “So it’s in that holding pattern because the appeal was filed.”

Council Member Laurel Deneen supported upholding the revocation, noting that the property had outstanding violations beyond the pest infestation.

However, she emphasized that she wanted the landlord to resolve the issues so the family could remain in the home.

“I do want to stress, as we move forward, that I want this to work out,” Deneen said. “I want the tenants to be able to stay in place and be able to get their license back. But that means if there’s any confusion…make sure you’re following up.”

With the appeal denied, Thiam must address the outstanding violations and apply for a new rental license, with the reapplication fee reduced by one-third.

Original Article