Elwell Farms developers and Ham Lake are at odds over how many parking spaces should be required for a proposed neighborhood clubhouse and swimming pool.

The developers want residents to walk or bike to the clubhouse, while city officials worry that too little parking could lead to congestion on nearby streets. The disagreement came to the forefront at the Ham Lake City Council’s Oct. 19 meeting.

Joseph Radach of Contour Development said the concept for Elwell Farms was developed two years ago and has evolved since. The development’s building partners requested a clubhouse, for which Contour submitted a building permit application in July.

Since then, there has been considerable discussion over parking requirements, prompting Contour to submit a written explanation of its position the previous week.

“I think you guys saw various clubhouses throughout the metro that have basically little to no parking,” Radach said. “And what we’re being asked to put in is 50 parking spaces, and it’s based on an occupancy of 200 people. I think the clubhouse is approximately 4,000 square feet. If you look at several of the houses in Ham Lake, Hidden Forest, Elwell Farms, those houses are probably bigger than the clubhouse.”

Radach said many of these houses had pools and could accommodate more people than the clubhouse. He questioned whether 50 parking spaces would be necessary for an amenity exclusive to Elwell Farms residents, even for events such as weddings or graduation parties.

“We’re trying to promote walkability in the neighborhood. We want people to be biking, walking to this amenity, not getting in their car and driving,” Radach said.

He added that the development’s building partner had constructed similar communities with an emphasis on walkability and neighborhood interaction. A 50-space parking lot, he said, would take away from what they were trying to accomplish.

“I’m not an environmentalist, but why would we put in a big sea of asphalt at the amenity?” Radach said.

Council Member Mike Van Kirk said he and Council Member Al Parranto had visited the area and determined that the building would require 120 parking spaces under city code. The city had discussed reducing that number to 50, but both council members questioned whether that would be enough.

Van Kirk said the clubhouse could host weddings, family reunions or swimming teams, creating a need for more parking than the developer anticipated. He also expressed concern about the small nearby intersection and the possibility of vehicles lining the neighborhood’s narrow streets.

“The can’s gonna be kicked to us later, and everyone’s gonna be screaming and whining about all of the parking along those roads,” Van Kirk said. “Not to mention those roads are so narrow that if a kid runs out in the middle, they could have a problem there.”

Van Kirk said Contour’s examples of similar developments were in higher-density neighborhoods where walkability made more sense. He worried that Ham Lake residents would be more likely to drive to the clubhouse, creating additional congestion.

“I think the whole thing should go to Planning and Zoning at the next meeting, and then we can review it,” Van Kirk said. “But just to cut to the chase, according to our own code, there should be 120 spots there.”

Radach disputed the suggestion that there had been an agreement on 50 spaces, saying the city’s code committee had come back to the developer with that number.

Radach said that when Contour met with the city in July, the developer proposed approximately 16 parking spaces. The city indicated that 19 spaces would be needed, along with proof that the site could accommodate twice that number.

Contour revised its plans and resubmitted, but Radach said the parking requirements continued to increase with each submission.

“We’re basically out of the construction season, and now we’re talking about 50 parking spaces,” Radach said. “That was thrown down upon us kind of out of the blue.”

Council Member Andrew Hallberg asked Radach to clarify the size of the development. Radach said Elwell Farms would include 107 houses and that the clubhouse would be exclusive to the neighborhood.

Ham Lake building and zoning official Mark Jones explained that the Elwell Farms proposal was not directly comparable to Contour’s other developments.

At three of those developments, Jones said, the farthest residents had to walk to reach the clubhouse was two or three blocks. Elwell Farms residents, by comparison, could have to travel a half-mile to reach the proposed clubhouse.

Jones added that the other examples were permitted under R-1 residential zoning, while Ham Lake’s code did not allow the same use, requiring the developers to seek approval through a planned unit development, or PUD.

Under the city’s code, the building would have to have a residential primary use. However, the PUD process allowed the developer to seek approval for a community center as a commercial use.

“The property itself is a commercial use,” Jones said. “So we have to look at it as a commercial use. And our code says that you have to provide paving for parking, and you have to provide adequate parking.”

Jones said the city also had to consider the pool’s occupancy load, adding that the size and use of the proposed building made it different from anything Ham Lake had previously considered. He said the pool would add a potential occupancy of another 166 people.

Parranto said this was the city’s first PUD and its first commercial building within a residential neighborhood, making it important for the Planning and Zoning Commission to review the proposal more closely.

Radach pointed out that no other community Contour had worked with had classified what the developer considered a residential amenity as a commercial use.

City Attorney Mark Berglund explained that other communities allowed such amenities in residential areas, while Ham Lake had approved the use through its PUD process. As a result, the building and property were zoned for commercial use.

Berglund added that the city had some flexibility when applying commercial requirements through the PUD process. Based on Jones’ occupancy calculations, the city’s code called for 120 parking spaces, but the PUD allowed the city to consider reducing that requirement to 50.

Berglund also clarified that the city had not made a final decision on the number of parking spaces required.

“You say this is being forced upon you; no decision has been made,” Berglund said.

He explained that discussions with city staff did not constitute a final decision. Contour still needed to complete its building permit application and go through the city’s review process.

Following discussion about the developer’s broader goals for Elwell Farms, Van Kirk emphasized that he appreciated what Contour had done in the city, despite taking a hard line on parking.

“The neighborhoods are going to be gorgeous. They are absolutely wonderful,” Van Kirk said. “We see all that. We just don’t want a problem ten years down the road with, you know, our perception of what we could have for a future problem.”

Both Berglund and Jones noted that additional approvals and information were needed for the pool, including occupancy requirements. Jones said he was also uncertain about state requirements for showers and other facilities. Radach said the architect had designed the building to meet state code.

The next step for Contour is to submit a commercial site plan to Ham Lake’s Planning and Zoning Commission, which will review the proposal at a future meeting.

Original Article