A proposed 106-home development along 125th Avenue Northeast failed to secure the five votes needed for approval from the Blaine City Council Oct. 19, with some members opposing a change from planned commercial and industrial use to residential development.
The council voted 4-3 in favor of the comprehensive plan amendment, one vote short of the required supermajority. Mayor Tim Sanders and Council Members Chris Ford, Tom Newland and Leslie Larson supported the amendment, while Council Members Terra Fleming, Jess Robertson and Chris Massoglia opposed it.
Community Development Director Sheila Sellman said the proposal would have rezoned properties at 3700 and 3900 125th Ave. NE from Farm Residential to Development Flex and amended the city’s comprehensive plan to change the designation from Planned Industrial/Planned Commercial to Low Density Residential.
The preliminary plat called for approximately 83 acres containing 106 single-family lots and 11 outlots, along with a conditional use permit to allow the homes within a Development Flex district.
Plans for the development dated back to May 2025, when a council workshop considered a proposal for 83 single-family lots and 91 townhomes. The council did not support a land-use change to allow the townhomes.
A revised plan presented in October 2025 called for 70-foot lots and twin homes, with a site plan that met the comprehensive plan’s minimum density requirements.
The council was receptive to those changes, but in April 2026, it denied a preliminary plat, comprehensive plan amendment and conditional use permit for a development containing 79 single-family homes and 56 twin-home lots. Council members continued to express concerns about attached housing and whether the proposal aligned with the city’s overall vision for the area.
At another workshop in June, the council was generally receptive to a plan for 106 detached single-family homes, including 78 homes on 70-foot lots developed by Pulte and 28 homes on 80-foot lots developed by Jonathan Homes.
Massoglia said he did not support the comprehensive plan amendment because he had consistently advocated for slowing residential development where possible and focusing on business and commercial growth.
He questioned whether changing land planned for industrial and commercial use to residential made sense.
“Especially with the commercial development that’s going in here, I think commercial would be a great fit for these 12 acres,” Massoglia said, “and with all the other industrial property we’ve been rearranging in the city, I think it would be wise to keep this as planned industrial/planned commercial.”
Fleming said she also opposed the amendment for several reasons. While she liked the development itself, she said the comprehensive plan existed for a reason.
“I think the clincher for me is when I look at the site plan and where it is, it is butting up right to where our proposed potential new fire station would be,” Fleming said. “And what I hear all the time from residents is, if I had only known, I never would have built this house here.”
Fleming said she did not believe residential development immediately next to a potential fire station was a good fit. She also wanted to slow growth where possible.
Larson questioned where the street would go if the commercial designation remained in place. Director of Engineering Daniel Schluender said the road would still extend east and connect to what had previously been platted near Zest Street, regardless of the zoning.
Ford said he liked the idea of commercial development but questioned whether smaller businesses could afford to build new stand-alone locations.
“It’s gonna be what Blaine residents don’t want: More Chipotles, more McDonald’s, the people who have the money to actually put the franchises in there,” Ford said. “And I’m just wondering what that vision was on the type of commercial properties to go in there, because to me this looks like a good fit for the housing to go in.”
Sanders said he did not believe the council had held many discussions about what types of commercial development should occupy the area.
He said he understood keeping part of the property designated for commercial use but would not support industrial development in the area. He viewed the housing proposal as an opportunity to finish developing the Lakes neighborhood.
Sanders acknowledged that a fire station would need some kind of buffer if built in the area but said the latest design was a positive step in the discussions.
“I think the applicants deserve to have that conversation as to what kinds of commercial might be an option, and what that would do to the impact of how the homes were platted out,” Sanders said, “but at the least, I think there’s been significant movement from the applicant in the direction of what Council had been initially asking for.”