The Blaine City Council unanimously approved changes to its criteria for conditional use permits Oct. 19, removing several subjective standards and adding more specific requirements despite concerns from council members about losing flexibility in their decisions.

Community Development Director Sheila Sellman said state law allows certain land uses through conditional use permits, provided they meet standards and criteria established in a city’s zoning ordinance. Cities can attach conditions to the permits to address potential concerns related to a proposed use and its location.

City staff proposed the amendments to clarify the criteria used to evaluate CUP applications.

Under the revised language, public infrastructure and services must be able to accommodate additional demand created by a proposed use. The previous language required that they not be excessively burdened.

The city also removed language requiring a proposed use to match the existing or intended character of the zoning district, instead focusing on compatibility with adjoining properties.

Other language eliminated from the ordinance included a requirement that the appearance of a proposed use not adversely affect adjacent properties and a provision requiring the use to be reasonably related to the city’s overall needs in the opinion of the council.

The revised zoning language requires a proposed use to be consistent with the purposes of the zoning code and the district where it would be located.

New language also requires consistency with the city’s comprehensive plan and adequate mitigation of traffic generated by the proposed use. A separate requirement for adequate utilities was removed.

Council Member Chris Massoglia said he appreciated the flexibility provided by some of the previous language, particularly the provision allowing the council to consider its own judgment.

Massoglia questioned how parking concerns would be addressed under the revised criteria, saying the council needed the flexibility to deny permits based on a variety of circumstances.

“As city council members and representatives, we’re very familiar with these neighborhoods, these driveways, these turn-ins, the traffic,” Massoglia said. “And I think that having some flexibility is a positive thing.”

Council Member Terra Fleming agreed with Massoglia’s concerns but said she was unsure how the city could address them.

Sellman said a proposed use that failed to meet parking requirements would not be brought forward for approval if conditions could not resolve the issue because it would not meet city code.

Massoglia pointed to a previous CUP denial in which the council determined there was inadequate parking. Sellman said other criteria that the proposal failed to meet had also contributed to that denial.

Massoglia maintained that simply meeting the parking requirements in the city code would not be sufficient in every situation.

City Attorney Eric Larson said the criteria addressing public welfare and safety would provide the council with a broader standard for considering concerns.

“The one you’d like to keep, I actually really want to strike,” Larson said. “And here’s why. Just because it’s conditional use doesn’t mean the Council can, on whim and caprice, grant or deny. So if it’s just their opinion without more, you can’t deny.”

Original Article