After neighbors complained that a West Tri Oak Circle rental was hosting weddings and parties that filled the road with cars, the East Bethel City Council unanimously adopted new short-term rental regulations Sept. 28.

Elizabeth Gorowsky said she and her husband live next door to the rental and that conditions had become untenable. She said bachelor and bachelorette parties and weddings had flooded the road with cars. She also expressed concern about drinking at the property.

“We’ve called the cops because we’ve been told to do that,” Gorowsky said. “And they’ve come, like Saturday, and told my husband that their hands are being tied by the City Council.”

Dave Saskowski said he lives across the lake from the rental and could hear every word being yelled from the property.

Suzanne Peterson said police had been called to the area the previous Saturday because of parking problems.

“If you want to have a wedding, or something big for 50 or 75 people, that is not what this ordinance is supposed to be about,” Peterson said. “Honestly, last Saturday, the police were called because there were problems with where the people were parking.”

Peterson also raised concerns about emergency access if a fire occurred at an overcrowded rental.

“It definitely has a negative impact on the neighborhood, but it’s also a bigger safety concern for the renters,” Peterson said. “It’s not OK that you can’t even get to the house.”

The ordinance adds parking requirements, habitability and fire inspections and an interim use permit process for rentals in the city’s shoreland areas. City Planner Eric Johnson said the IUP process would allow more public input on higher-capacity rentals.

Johnson said the number of short-term rentals will likely increase as the market attracts more investors. He said East Bethel modeled its ordinance on regulations in other communities but tried to keep it as simple as possible.

Council Member Suzanne Erkel said the ordinance did not specifically address yard parking or requirements for impervious surfaces.

Mayor Ardie Anderson said those issues could be handled through the IUP process.

Johnson said parking plans would receive greater scrutiny for properties with six or seven bedrooms than for those with two. The plans would have to address street parking, parking capacity, maneuvering and other city requirements.

Resident Tim Bussey agreed that the city should protect neighbors and identify problem rentals, but he urged the council to clarify parts of the ordinance. He cited what he viewed as a gap involving rentals of 21 to 30 days, unclear penalties for repeated violations, language governing nonconforming properties and inconsistent references to administrative licenses and IUPs.

“Looking at the IUP as well, it’s a very lengthy process, with a lot of bullet points in there,” Bussey said. “It could be anything from a floor plan layout to a landscaping plan that could be required in an IUP. It’s unclear whether you’d require that in a short-term rental, for example.”

Bussey said the city should make the process clear for rental operators. He also suggested revising the IUP standards for higher-intensity rentals, which he said represent about 1% of rentals and serve groups of 13 or more.

The council also amended Chapter 50 of the city code to clarify the distinction between traditional residential rentals and short-term rentals. The amendment clarified that short-term rentals remain subject to the city’s rental-license requirement.

Johnson said the city had contacted the West Tri Oak Circle property and advised that a rental license was required under the existing ordinance.

City Attorney Mark Berglund said the amendment returned to the original licensing language while clarifying the difference between traditional and short-term rentals.

Original Article