With Council Member Amy Faanes casting the lone dissenting vote, the St. Francis City Council voted 4-1 Sept. 8 to approve the Rum River Fire District’s 2027 budget following discussion of internal errors that contributed to an increase.
Fire Chief David Schmidt said staff had directed the district to review its initial budget for possible changes and reductions. During that process, the district discovered several items in the 2026 budget had been underfunded and would have carried over into 2027.
The district shifted capital expenditures to its operating budget to offset those costs. The final budget totals $1,046,200, an overall decrease of $10,000 from the initial proposal.
Schmidt said the errors were corrected internally at no additional cost. The budget received unanimous approval from the fire board in August and from the Bethel City Council at its most recent meeting.
Council Member Joe Muehlbauer said he wanted to see the budget reduced further but called the $10,000 decrease significant, given the 2026 costs that will carry into 2027.
“Again, that’s not a lot, but at this time where the city’s overall levy is with the district, I wanted it to at least get down to nine and a half. We got below that,” Muehlbauer said.
Faanes thanked the district for reducing the budget by $10,000 but said she could not understand how its budget had risen from $426,000 in 2021 to more than $1 million.
“The call volume has stayed relatively stable between 2021 and now, according to the numbers that I got off of our meeting,” Faanes said. “Primarily, of the $1,046,000, over half of that is personnel. And the personnel budget is way more than what the budget was just five years ago.”
Faanes said she had expected the fire district to cost less but believed it appeared to be costing more.
“I think we could do more to do internal training that wouldn’t cost an outside instructor, because I know those costs are pretty high,” Faanes said. “And I think we could do more in making, not all of the fire department get paged out to every call.”
Council Member Kevin Robinson asked whether Faanes had spoken with Schmidt, as other council members had. Faanes said she had not because she was out of town for part of the time and believed she understood the information presented to her.
“Everyone should seek knowledge when they have the opportunity,” Robinson said. “I didn’t have a problem with this at this go-around.”
Robinson said that although costs were rising, he believed Schmidt would be a good steward of the district’s money.
Mayor Mark Vogel said the fire district, as he had previously warned, was not going to save the city money. He said the goal was instead to limit the size of future budget increases.
“Unfortunately, there’s multiple things that went into this, including a website that costs more than we thought, the COLA that wasn’t accounted for correctly, etc.,” Vogel said. “The fire department is in a very difficult spot.”
Vogel said residents expect immediate emergency service, influenced in part by television shows and movies depicting firefighters arriving within seconds. The district could provide that level of service, he said, but doing so would be expensive.
“We can provide those kinds of services. It’s a difficult balance,” Vogel said.