Several residents and some Ham Lake City Council members raised concerns July 20 about a new Anoka County Sheriff’s Office pilot program involving drones and Flock automated license plate reader technology.
Sheriff Brad Wise recently signed a $174,999 contract with the vendor. Ham Lake contracts with the Sheriff’s Office for law enforcement services.
Ham Lake resident Christine Dahlman said she became aware of Flock after Isanti residents and the city’s mayor said they had not known cameras had been installed there. The issue gained attention after a camera was cut down and information about the cameras began circulating on Facebook, she said.
Dahlman said she then asked Mayor Brian Kirkham whether Ham Lake had the cameras and was told he did not know.
Dahlman read from what she described as Wise’s written response to questions about the program. She said Wise explained that the Sheriff’s Office had not discussed placing the technology in county right of way in Ham Lake before it was installed.
She said the response also stated that one camera is near Highway 65 and Bunker Lake Boulevard.
“My concern is not whether or not a permit exists,” Dahlman said. “My concern is transparency. A surveillance system was placed into our community without a conversation with the city or notice to the residents.”
Dahlman said she voted for Wise but was disappointed by what she described as a lack of transparency.
She also said the contract allows Flock to retain data indefinitely and use it to “provide, maintain and improve services.” Dahlman questioned what the company could do with the data and whether the contract conflicted with state data-retention requirements.
Resident Levi Boyer said he did not object to cameras in a vacuum, but he was concerned about the lack of transparency surrounding the Sheriff’s Office’s implementation of the technology and its use of artificial intelligence.
Boyer, who said he serves on the executive committee of the Senate District 31 Republican Party, said he hoped opponents would speak to officials in every Anoka County city. He said he wanted Ham Lake to be the first to formally oppose the program.
Jacob Nordby said residents did not know exactly how Flock would use data gathered by the cameras. He questioned whether the company could create derivative data products or otherwise use information gathered through the system.
Resident Kelsey Nordby said the issue was not about politics but whether installing Flock cameras was the right decision for a neighborhood.
“I want our families to be safe,” Nordby said. “I want law enforcement to have the tools they need to solve serious crimes. But I also believe that before we install a system that records every vehicle entering or leaving our neighborhoods, we owe it to ourselves to ask some pretty difficult questions.”
After the Sheriff’s Office’s monthly report, Kirkham asked Lt. Anthony Mendoza whether Ham Lake could opt out of the program.
Mendoza did not directly answer whether the city could opt out. He said Columbia Heights had canceled its own Flock contract but that Ham Lake was included in the county initiative because it contracts with the Sheriff’s Office.
Mendoza said the goal is to expand the camera network throughout Anoka County, including Ham Lake. He said the cameras would not be installed in neighborhoods but in county right of way.
In response to a question from Council Member Al Parranto, Mendoza said the cameras capture vehicle characteristics. An officer could, for example, search for a white vehicle with a blue door.
“It will tell me all of the vehicles that have been captured on that network that match that description, and where,” Mendoza said.
State law allows the Sheriff’s Office to retain camera data for 60 days, Mendoza said. The office retains it for 30 days, after which the images are no longer accessible, he said.
Mendoza said the system’s audit log retains search criteria, including information about which terms were entered into particular fields.
Flock does not capture personal data, Mendoza said, and no federal agency will have access to Sheriff’s Office data.
“Currently, we share with a healthy amount of agencies,” Mendoza said. “I don’t have the exact number on me. But we have parameters in place that limit who we share with. And the justification for why we share that is standardized.”
The Sheriff’s Office performs an audit every 30 days and undergoes an external audit every two years, Mendoza said. He said the auditing requirements apply to automated license plate reader systems and body-worn cameras.
Mendoza said drones in the drone-assisted response program would be deployed in response to calls and would not be used for continuous monitoring. Using the drones for continuous surveillance would violate state law, he said.
When a vehicle alert is generated, officers must verify that it is the vehicle they are seeking and independently run its license plate through the computer-aided dispatch system, Mendoza said. Location data is retained for 30 days, he said.
Mendoza said the drones would travel to coordinates associated with a call and capture an image once they arrived. He estimated the drones would arrive in the county 16 to 18 weeks after the meeting.
Council Member Andrew Hallberg said that although a particular use might be legal now, allowing it could make it easier to push the limits further over time.
“I struggle with this because I get that there’s so many instances where this could be beneficial,” Hallberg said. “Where it could help track people, and get the bad people where they belong. … I think it was Ben Franklin that said, ‘Those who would give up basic liberties for temporary safety deserve neither liberty nor safety.’”
Hallberg said the U.S. does not currently allow weapons to be placed on such drones but that weaponized drones are being used elsewhere in the world. He said he was concerned that incremental changes could eventually normalize uses of the technology that Americans would not now accept.
Council Member Jim Doyle said people are likely photographed several times when traveling to destinations such as a Minnesota Twins game in the metro area.
“And maybe we don’t want to take that further, I get that,” Doyle said. “But if you think you’re not being listened to and watched already, you’re wrong because you already are.”